Our Menus

A Modern Steakhouse

In Historic Downtown New Albany

Join Us For

Dinner

  • RAW BAR
  • Creekstone Farm Filet Carpaccio24

Lemon, olive oil, Maldon, caper berry, parmesan, arugula

  • Oysters on the Half Shell

East Coast (3) — 9
West Coast (3) — 13.50

  • Brooklyn's Shrimp Cocktail22

Jumbo shrimp, cocktail sauce

  • Seafood TowerMKT

3 East Coast, 3 West Coast, 6 cocktail shrimp, ahi tuna tartare, crackers + wontons

  • Ahi Tuna Tartare21

Cucumber, yuzu kosho aioli, sweet soy, crispy garlic

consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness.

  • STARTERS
  • San Marzano Tomato and Basil Pesto Soup9

Parmesan, focaccia

  • Butchers Chopped Salad10

SPRING MIX, ROMA CRUNCH, SMOKED BACON, TOMATOES, CUCUMBERS, CROUTONS, BUTTERMILK DRESSING

  • Brooklyn Wedge12

SMOKED BLEU CHEESE DRESSING, BACON, TOMATOES, BRIOCHE GREMOLATA

  • Caesar Salad12

ROMA CRUNCH LETTUCE, PARMESAN REGGIANO, HOUSE CAESAR, BRIOCHE CROUTONS

  • Roasted Candy Stripe & Gold Beet Salad16

Arugula, pickled fennel, goat cheese, blood orange-champagne vinaigrette

Additions:

Anchovy +3, Salmon +16, Shrimp (4) +12, Flat Iron +21, Chicken +12

  • SHARABLES
  • The Butcher's Board22

rotating chef’s whim

  • Baked Goat Cheese21

tomato jam, basil pesto, focaccia 

  • Icy Blue Mussels24

White wine, roasted garlic, basil pesto, focaccia

  • Calabrian-Honey Glazed Chicken Lollipop19

Celery root puree

  • Crab & Goat Cheese Spring Rolls19

Pickled carrots, sweet chili

  • Braised Octopus & Crispy Calamari27

Arrabbiata, Castelvetrano olive, caper berry

  • Braised Pork Belly15

Smoked gouda grits, raspberry gastrique, warm apple chutney

  • STEAKHOUSE SIDES
  • Creamy Red Potatoes9

BOURSIN & SCALLIONS

  • Lemon Charred Broccolini9
  • Butchers Baked Potato7

(LOADED +2)

  • Asparagus9

BLACK TRUFFLE BEARNAISE

  • Parmesan + Truffle Frites9
  • BROOKLYN SIDES
  • Mac + Cheese13

Jarlsberg, cheddar, parmesan bread crumb crust

  • Brussel Sprouts12

Sorghum mustard dressing, lardon, pickled fennel

  • Lobster Mac27

(Upgrade available +24)

  • Roasted Mushrooms12

WORCESTERSHIRE SOY BUTTER

  • Parmesan Risotto & Fava Bean12
  • We work with local farmers to provide the best quality!
  • - Exectuive Chef, Scott Edwards
  • Brooklyn's Signature Steaks

SERVED WITH A BUTCHER’S CHOPPED SALAD AND ONE STEAKHOUSE SIDE. UPGRADE TO ANY PREMIUM SALAD OR SOUP FOR +2 OR BROOKLYN’S SIDES +3

  • Creekstone Farm Picanha

8 oz. – 39

  • Creekstone Farm NY Strip

12 oz. – 46

  • Creekstone Farm Ribeye

12 oz. – 48

  • Creekstone Farm Filet

7 oz. – 65

BROOKLYN’S SIGNATURE STEAKS SPLIT PLATE CHARGE +3

  • SPECIALTY CUTS
  • Cowboy Ribeye

18 oz. – 69

  • Prime Ribeye

14 oz. – 66

  • Creekstone Farm Porterhouse

32 oz. – MKT

  • STYLES
  • Oscar29

Lump crab, asparagus, black truffle béarnaise

  • Brooklyn9

Smoked bleu cheese butter, bacon, grilled onions

  • Forager9

Mushrooms, grilled onions, Worcestershire butter

  • Black and Bleu9

Toasted gorgonzola, black currant demi-glace

  • ACCOMPANIMENTS

fancy additions for your steak!

  • Au Poivre4
  • Basil Pesto6
  • Smoked Bleu Butter5
  • Worcestershire Butter4
  • Black Truffle Bearnaise5
  • Black Currant Demi-Glace5
  • Bordelaise6
  • Lump Crab24
  • Cold Water Lobster Tail33
  • (4) Shrimp12
  • ENTREES
  • Black Hawk Farm Beef Osso Bucco39

Horseradish-celery root puree, crispy wild mushroom, gremolata

  • Verlasso Salmon36

Creamy polenta, lemon charred broccolini, roasted red pepper bruschetta

  • Pan-Seared Chicken33

Creamy polenta, wild mushroom, Marsala demi, crispy sage

  • Bucatini Carbonara24

Shallot, lardon, fava bean, parmesan

  • Chicken Fettuccine Alfredo21

Asparagus, roasted tomato, parmesan

  • Lasagna Bolognese28

Veal, ricotta, parmesan